What are little worlds made of? Stellar abundances and the building blocks of planets

TL;DR

This paper examines how stellar elemental abundances, especially the C/O ratio, relate to planet formation and composition, arguing that stellar chemistry reflects inherited dust composition rather than planet-induced signatures.

Contribution

It critically analyzes the link between stellar abundances and planet composition, emphasizing the role of inherited dust and Galactic chemical evolution over planet formation signatures.

Findings

C/O ratio is close to solar and varies little among nearby dwarf stars.

Stars with C/O ≥ 1 are extremely rare (<0.1%).

Planetary chemistry is influenced more by dust inheritance than stellar gas composition.

Abstract

If the photospheres of solar-type stars represent the composition of circumstellar disks from which any planets formed, spectroscopic determinations of stellar elemental abundances offer information on the composition of those planets, including smaller, rocky planets. In particular, the C/O ratio is proposed to be a key determinant of the composition of solids that condense from disk gas and are incorporated into planets. Also, planets may leave chemical signatures on the photospheres of their host stars by sequestering heavy elements, or by being accreted by the stars. The presence, absence, and composition of planets could be revealed by small differences in the relative abundances between stars. I critically examine these scenarios and show that (i) a model of Galactic chemical evolution predicts that the C/O ratio is expected to be close to the solar value and vary little between dwarf stars in the solar neighborhood; (ii) spectroscopic surveys of M dwarf stars limit the occurrence of stars with C/O $\gtrsim 1$ to $<10^{-3}$; and (iii) planetesimal chemistry will be controlled by the composition of oxygen-rich dust inherited from the molecular cloud and processed in a dust-rich environment, not a gas with the stellar composition. A second generation of more reduced planetesimals could be produced by re-equilibration of some material with dust-depleted gas. Finally, I discuss how minor differences in relative abundances between stars that correlate with condensation temperature can be explained by dust-gas segregation, perhaps in circumstellar disks, rather than planet formation.