Measurements of EUV Coronal Holes and Open Magnetic Flux

TL;DR

This study develops an automated method to measure and compare coronal hole areas and magnetic flux using EUV images from multiple solar observatories, revealing cycle-dependent variations and emphasizing the importance of low-latitude holes.

Contribution

It introduces an automated detection routine for coronal holes in EUV images and compares measurements across different instruments and models, highlighting discrepancies and improvements in low-latitude hole detection.

Findings

Coronal hole area varies between 5% and 17% of the solar surface.

Open magnetic flux ranges from 2 to 5 x 10^22 Mx, with cycle dependence.

AIA/EUVI measurements show higher flux and better low-latitude hole detection than EIT.

Abstract

Coronal holes are regions on the Sun's surface that map the foot-prints of open magnetic field lines. We have developed an automated routine to detect and track boundaries of long-lived coronal holes using full-disk EUV images obtained by SoHO:EIT, SDO:AIA, and STEREO:EUVI. We measure coronal hole areas and magnetic flux in these holes, and compare the measurements with calculations by the PFSS model. It is shown that, from 1996 through 2010, the total area of coronal holes measured with EIT images varies between 5$\%$ and 17$\%$ of the total solar surface area, and the total unsigned open flux varies between $2-5 \times 10^{22}$ Mx. The solar cycle dependence of these measurements are similar to the PFSS results, but the model yields larger hole areas and greater open flux than observed by EIT. The AIA/EUVI measurements from 2010-2013 show coronal hole area coverage of 5-10$\%$ of the total surface area, with significant contribution from low latitudes, which is under-represented by EIT. AIA/EUVI have measured much enhanced open magnetic flux in the range of $2-4 \times 10^{22}$ Mx, which is about twice the flux measured by EIT, and matches with the PFSS calculated open flux, with discrepancies in the location and strength of coronal holes. A detailed comparison between the three measurements (by EIT, AIA-EUVI, and PFSS) indicates that coronal holes in low latitudes contribute significantly to the total open magnetic flux. These low-latitude coronal holes are not well measured with either the He I 10830 line in previous studies, or EIT EUV images; neither are they well captured by the static PFSS model. The enhanced observations from AIA/EUVI allow a more accurate measure of these low latitude coronal holes, and their contribution to open magnetic flux.