A composition dependent energy scale and the determination of the cosmic ray primary mass in the ankle region

TL;DR

This paper introduces an analytical method to assess how composition-dependent energy calibration affects cosmic ray primary mass determination, using the Pierre Auger Observatory's surface detectors as a case study.

Contribution

It develops a new analytical approach to evaluate biases in cosmic ray composition analysis caused by energy calibration dependent on primary mass.

Findings

Calibration biases can significantly affect composition measurements.

The method quantifies the impact of composition dependence on energy calibration.

Application to AMIGA demonstrates the method's practical utility.

Abstract

At present there are still several open questions about the origin of the ultra high energy cosmic rays. However, great progress in this area has been made in recent years due to the data collected by the present generation of ground based detectors like the Pierre Auger Observatory and Telescope Array. In particular, it is believed that the study of the composition of the cosmic rays as a function of energy can play a fundamental role for the understanding of the origin of the cosmic rays. The observatories belonging to this generation are composed of arrays of surface detectors and fluorescence telescopes. The duty cycle of the fluorescence telescopes is ~10 % in contrast with the ~100 % of the surface detectors. Therefore, the energy calibration of the events observed by the surface detectors is performed by using a calibration curve obtained from a set of high quality events observed in coincidence by both types of detectors. The advantage of this method is that the reconstructed energy of the events observed by the surface detectors becomes almost independent of simulations of the showers because just a small part of the reconstructed energy, obtained from the fluorescence telescopes, comes from simulations. However, the calibration curve obtained in this way depends on the composition of the cosmic rays, which can introduce biases in composition analyses when parameters with a strong dependence on primary energy are considered. In this work we develop an analytical method to study these effects. We consider AMIGA, the low energy extension of the Pierre Auger Observatory corresponding to the surface detectors, to illustrate the use of the method.