Evidence against a strong thermal inversion in HD 209458 b from high-dispersion spectroscopy

TL;DR

High-resolution infrared spectroscopy of HD 209458 b shows no evidence of thermal inversion, suggesting its atmosphere is nearly isothermal or the inversion signal is heavily muted, challenging previous assumptions of a strong thermal inversion.

Contribution

This study applies high-dispersion spectroscopy to directly test for thermal inversions in HD 209458 b, providing new constraints on its atmospheric temperature structure.

Findings

No significant CO emission or absorption detected.

Evidence suggests the atmosphere is nearly isothermal.

Full-disc inversion layer in the 1 bar to 1 mbar range is ruled out.

Abstract

Broadband secondary-eclipse measurements of hot Jupiters have indicated the existence of atmospheric thermal inversions, but their presence is difficult to determine from broadband measurements because of degeneracies between molecular abundances and temperature structure. We apply high-resolution (R = 100 000) infrared spectroscopy to probe the temperature-pressure profile of HD 209458 b. This bright, transiting hot-Jupiter has long been considered the gold standard for a hot Jupiter with an inversion layer, but this has been challenged in recent publications. We observed the thermal dayside emission of HD 209458 b with CRIRES / VLT during three nights, targeting the carbon monoxide band at 2.3 microns. Thermal inversions give rise to emission features, which means that detecting emission lines in the planetary spectrum, as opposed to absorption lines, would be direct evidence of a region in which the temperature increases with altitude. We do not detect any significant absorption or emission of CO in the dayside spectrum of HD 209458 b, although cross-correlation with template spectra either with CO absorption lines or with weak emission at the core of the lines show a low-significance correlation signal with a signal-to-noise ratio of 3 - 3.5. Models with strong CO emission lines show a weak anti-correlation with similar or lower significance levels. Furthermore, we found no evidence of absorption or emission from H2O at these wavelengths. The non-detection of CO in the dayside spectrum of HD 209458 b is interesting in light of a previous CO detection in the transmission spectrum. That there is no signal indicates that HD 209458 b either has a nearly isothermal atmosphere or that the signal is heavily muted. Assuming a clear atmosphere, we can rule out a full-disc dayside inversion layer in the pressure range 1 bar to 1 mbar.