Quadratic Conditional Lower Bounds for String Problems and Dynamic Time Warping

TL;DR

This paper establishes that classic string similarity measures like edit distance and dynamic time warping cannot be computed faster than quadratic time under the Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis, even for simplified cases.

Contribution

It proves quadratic-time lower bounds for these measures, generalizes previous hardness results, and introduces a framework for proving similar bounds for other similarity measures.

Findings

No strongly subquadratic algorithms for these measures unless SETH fails

Quadratic-time hardness extends to edit distance with fixed costs

Hardness results apply to longest palindromic and tandem subsequence problems

Abstract

Classic similarity measures of strings are longest common subsequence and Levenshtein distance (i.e., the classic edit distance). A classic similarity measure of curves is dynamic time warping. These measures can be computed by simple $O(n^2)$ dynamic programming algorithms, and despite much effort no algorithms with significantly better running time are known. We prove that, even restricted to binary strings or one-dimensional curves, respectively, these measures do not have strongly subquadratic time algorithms, i.e., no algorithms with running time $O(n^{2-\varepsilon})$ for any $\varepsilon > 0$, unless the Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis fails. We generalize the result to edit distance for arbitrary fixed costs of the four operations (deletion in one of the two strings, matching, substitution), by identifying trivial cases that can be solved in constant time, and proving quadratic-time hardness on binary strings for all other cost choices. This improves and generalizes the known hardness result for Levenshtein distance [Backurs, Indyk STOC'15] by the restriction to binary strings and the generalization to arbitrary costs, and adds important problems to a recent line of research showing conditional lower bounds for a growing number of quadratic time problems. As our main technical contribution, we introduce a framework for proving quadratic-time hardness of similarity measures. To apply the framework it suffices to construct a single gadget, which encapsulates all the expressive power necessary to emulate a reduction from satisfiability. Finally, we prove quadratic-time hardness for longest palindromic subsequence and longest tandem subsequence via reductions from longest common subsequence, showing that conditional lower bounds based on the Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis also apply to string problems that are not necessarily similarity measures.