Conditions on Ramsey non-equivalence

TL;DR

This paper investigates conditions under which different graphs are not Ramsey equivalent, showing that for many classes, parameters like chromatic number distinguish non-isomorphic graphs in the context of Ramsey theory.

Contribution

It extends known results by demonstrating that chromatic number often distinguishes non-Ramsey-equivalent graphs, and shows specific classes like stars, paths, and small graphs are uniquely characterized.

Findings

Chromatic number distinguishes many non-isomorphic graphs in Ramsey theory.

Stars, paths, and small graphs are not Ramsey equivalent to any other connected graphs.

Certain classes of trees and graphs with clique-reduction properties are uniquely identified by their Ramsey equivalence.

Abstract

Given a graph H, a graph G is called a Ramsey graph of H if there is a monochromatic copy of H in every coloring of the edges of G with two colors. Two graphs G, H are called Ramsey equivalent if they have the same set of Ramsey graphs. Fox et al. [J. Combin. Theory Ser. B 109 (2014), 120--133] asked whether there are two non-isomorphic connected graphs that are Ramsey equivalent. They proved that a clique is not Ramsey equivalent to any other connected graph. Results of Nesetril et al. showed that any two graphs with different clique number [Combinatorica 1(2) (1981), 199--202] or different odd girth [Comment. Math. Univ. Carolin. 20(3) (1979), 565--582] are not Ramsey equivalent. These are the only structural graph parameters we know that "distinguish" two graphs in the above sense. This paper provides further supportive evidence for a negative answer to the question of Fox et al. by claiming that for wide classes of graphs, chromatic number is a distinguishing parameter. In addition, it is shown here that all stars and paths and all connected graphs on at most 5 vertices are not Ramsey equivalent to any other connected graph. Moreover two connected graphs are not Ramsey equivalent if they belong to a special class of trees or to classes of graphs with clique-reduction properties.