Emergence of non-zonal coherent structures

TL;DR

This paper investigates how large-scale coherent structures like jets and vortices emerge in planetary turbulence, using a barotropic beta-plane model and a statistical theory called S3T to analyze their formation, stability, and characteristics.

Contribution

It introduces a statistical framework (S3T) to analytically predict the emergence and properties of non-zonal and zonal structures in turbulent flows, validated by nonlinear simulations.

Findings

Non-zonal structures emerge before zonal jets as energy input increases.

Analytic bifurcation points for structure formation are derived.

Numerical simulations confirm the predicted scale, amplitude, and phase speed of structures.

Abstract

Planetary turbulence is observed to self-organize into large-scale structures such as zonal jets and coherent vortices. One of the simplest models that retains the relevant dynamics of turbulent self-organization is a barotropic flow in a beta-plane channel with turbulence sustained by random stirring. Non-linear integrations of this model show that as the energy input rate of the forcing is increased, the homogeneity of the flow is first broken by the emergence of non-zonal, coherent, westward propagating structures and at larger energy input rates by the emergence of zonal jets. The emergence of both non-zonal coherent structures and zonal jets is studied using a statistical theory, Stochastic Structural Stability Theory (S3T). S3T directly models a second-order approximation to the statistical mean turbulent state and allows the identification of statistical turbulent equilibria and study of their stability. Using S3T, the bifurcation properties of the homogeneous state in barotropic beta-plane turbulence are determined. Analytic expressions for the zonal and non-zonal large-scale coherent flows that emerge as a result of structural instability are obtained and the equilibration of the incipient instabilities is studied through numerical integrations of the S3T dynamical system. The dynamics underlying the formation of zonal jets are also investigated. It is shown that zonal jets form from the upgradient momentum fluxes that result from the shearing of the eddies by the emerging infinitesimal large-scale flow. Finally, numerical simulations of the nonlinear equations confirm the characteristics (scale, amplitude and phase speed) of the structures predicted by S3T, even in highly non-linear parameter regimes such as the regime of zonostrophic turbulence.