Comment on "Can disorder really enhance superconductivity?"

TL;DR

This paper critiques a previous work on whether disorder can enhance superconductivity, offering an alternative perspective and addressing inaccuracies in the prior comment.

Contribution

It provides an alternative interpretation to the claim that disorder enhances superconductivity and corrects misconceptions in the previous comment.

Findings

Disputes the claim that disorder enhances superconductivity

Provides an alternative theoretical perspective

Addresses inaccuracies in prior comment

Abstract

The paper by Mayoh and Garcia-Garcia [arXiv:1412.0029v1] is entitled "Can disorder really enhance superconductivity?". In our opinion, the answer given by the authors is not satisfactory, and we present the alternative picture. Our reply to the comment [arXiv:1502.06282] is added in the end, in order to reveal a series of untrue statements contained in it.