Biases in the inferred mass-to-light ratio of globular clusters: no need for variations in the stellar mass function

TL;DR

This study shows that biases in dynamical mass estimates of globular clusters, caused by assumptions about mass segregation and mass function, explain observed discrepancies without needing IMF variations.

Contribution

The paper demonstrates that biases from mass segregation and mass function flattening account for mass-to-light ratio discrepancies, negating the need for IMF variations.

Findings

Bias in inferred mass increases with metallicity.

Mass segregation and mass function flattening have opposing effects.

Kinematical data can constrain black hole populations in GCs.

Abstract

From a study of the integrated light properties of 200 globular clusters (GCs) in M31, Strader et al. found that the mass-to-light ratios are lower than what is expected from simple stellar population (SSP) models with a `canonical' stellar initial mass function (IMF), with the discrepancy being larger at high metallicities. We use dynamical multi-mass models, that include a prescription for equipartition, to quantify the bias in the inferred dynamical mass as the result of the assumption that light follows mass. For a universal IMF and a metallicity dependent present day mass function we find that the inferred mass from integrated light properties systematically under estimates the true mass, and that the bias is more important at high metallicities, as was found for the M31 GCs. We show that mass segregation and a flattening of the mass function have opposing effects of similar magnitude on the mass inferred from integrated properties. This makes the mass-to-light ratio as derived from integrated properties an inadequate probe of the low-mass end of the stellar mass function. There is, therefore, no need for variations in the IMF, nor the need to invoke depletion of low-mass stars, to explain the observations. Finally, we find that the retention fraction of stellar-mass black holes (BHs) is an equally important parameter in understanding the mass segregation bias. We speculatively put forward to idea that kinematical data of GCs can in fact be used to constrain the total mass in stellar-mass BHs in GCs.