Field topologies in ideal and near ideal magnetohydrodynamics and vortex dynamics

TL;DR

This paper reviews magnetic field topology in ideal and near-ideal MHD, discussing flux conservation, topological breakage, and the formation of current sheets, with implications for solar corona dynamics and energy dissipation.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive analysis of magnetic topology, including the Parker Magnetostatic Theorem and the role of current sheets in topological changes, advancing understanding of MHD turbulence.

Findings

Magnetic flux conservation is fundamental but challenging to achieve numerically.

Field topology breakage leads to current sheet formation and dissipation.

Energy is stored in ideal MHD structures despite small resistivity.

Abstract

Magnetic field topology frozen in ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) and its breakage in near ideal MHD are reviewed in two parts. The first part gives a physically complete description of the frozen in field topology, taking magnetic flux conservation as fundamental and treating four topics, Eulerian and Lagrangian descriptions of MHD, Chandrasekhar-Kendall and Euler-potential field representations, magnetic helicity, and inviscid vortex dynamics in comparison to ideal MHD. A corollary clarifies the challenge of achieving a high degree of the frozen in condition in numerical MHD. The second part treats field topology breakage centered on the Parker Magnetostatic Theorem on a general incompatibility of a continuous magnetic field with the dual demand of force free equilibrium and an arbitrarily prescribed, 3D field topology. Preserving field topology as a global constraint readily results in formation of tangential magnetic discontinuities, i.e., electric current sheets of zero thickness. A similar incompatibility is present in the steady, force and thermal balance of a heated radiating fluid subject to an anisotropic thermal flux conducted strictly along the frozen in magnetic field in the low beta limit. In a weakly resistive fluid the thinning of current sheets by these incompatibilities inevitably results in sheet dissipation, resistive heating and topological changes in the field despite the small resistivity. Faraday induction drives but also macroscopically limits this mode of energy dissipation, storing free energy in self organized, ideal MHD structures. This property of MHD turbulence captured by the Taylor hypothesis is reviewed in relation to the Sun's corona, calling for a basic quantitative description of the breakdown of flux conservation in the low resistivity limit. A cylindrical, initial boundary value problem provides specificity in the review.