A New Perspective on Scale Uncertainties for Diboson Processes

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to estimating scale uncertainties in diboson production by including the complex phase of scales, significantly improving the reliability of perturbative predictions.

Contribution

It demonstrates that considering the complex phase of scales and resumming these effects greatly enhances the accuracy of scale uncertainty estimates in diboson processes.

Findings

Resummed scale uncertainties are 13-16% at LO.

Including complex phase improves LO and NLO compatibility.

Method extends to higher-order calculations and other LHC processes.

Abstract

The electroweak diboson production cross-sections are known to receive large radiative corrections beyond leading-order (LO), approaching up to 60% at next-to-leading order (NLO), compared to the scale uncertainties which are in the range 1-5% at LO. If the scale uncertainties are to be taken seriously, the NLO predictions are as much as 30 sigma away from their LO counterpart suggesting a very poor convergence of the perturbation theory. In this paper, we show that there is a second source of scale uncertainty which has not been considered in the literature, namely the complex phase of the scales, which can lead to large perturbative corrections. Using the formalism of soft-collinear effective theory, we resum these large contributions from the complex phase, finding that the scale uncertainties in fixed-order calculations can be grossly underestimated compared to the resummed predictions, which have uncertainties as large as 13-16% at LO. Even at NLO, we find that the scale uncertainties are marginally higher than previously estimated, depending on the choice of scale. Using our method of scale variation, the compatibility of LO and NLO results within the scale uncertainties is vastly improved so that the perturbation theory can be relied upon. This method of scale variation can be easily extended to beyond NLO calculations as well as other LHC processes.