The state of globular clusters at birth II: primordial binaries

TL;DR

This study uses simulations to explore the initial binary star populations in globular clusters, finding that data are consistent with a universal initial binary fraction and that different initial conditions can produce similar present-day observations.

Contribution

It demonstrates that initial binary fractions and densities can be constrained by comparing simulations with observations, supporting a universal initial binary fraction hypothesis.

Findings

Data are consistent with a universal initial binary fraction near unity.

Degeneracy exists between high initial binary fractions with high densities and low fractions with moderate densities.

Binary fractions outside the half-mass radius help distinguish initial conditions.

Abstract

(abridged) In this paper, we constrain the properties of primordial binary populations in Galactic globular clusters using the MOCCA Monte Carlo code for cluster evolution. Our results are compared to the observations of Milone et al. (2012) using the photometric binary populations as proxies for the true underlying distributions, in order to test the hypothesis that the data are consistent with an universal initial binary fraction near unity and the binary orbital parameter distributions of Kroupa (1995). With the exception of a few possible outliers, we find that the data are to first-order consistent with the universality hypothesis. Specifically, the present-day binary fractions inside the half-mass radius r$_{\rm h}$ can be reproduced assuming either high initial binary fractions near unity with a dominant soft binary component as in the Kroupa distribution combined with high initial densities (10$^4$-10$^6$ M$_{\odot}$ pc$^{-3}$), or low initial binary fractions ($\sim$ 5-10%) with a dominant hard binary component combined with moderate initial densities near their present-day values (10$^2$-10$^3$ M$_{\odot}$ pc$^{-3}$). This apparent degeneracy can be broken using the binary fractions outside r$_{\rm h}$- only high initial binary fractions with a significant soft component combined with high initial densities can contribute to reproducing the observed anti-correlation between the binary fractions outside r$_{\rm h}$ and the total cluster mass. We further illustrate using the simulated present-day binary orbital parameter distributions and the technique introduced in Leigh et al. (2012) that the relative fractions of hard and soft binaries can be used to further constrain the initial cluster density and mass-density relation. Our results favour an initial mass-density relation of the form r$_{\rm h} \propto$ M$_{\rm clus}^{\alpha}$ with $\alpha <$ 1/3.