Arithmetical Tugs of War and Benford's Law

TL;DR

This paper explores how the interplay between multiplication and addition processes in data generation influences adherence to Benford's Law, emphasizing the role of magnitude and skewness in digital distribution patterns.

Contribution

It introduces the concept of arithmetical tugs of war, analyzing how combined additive and multiplicative processes affect Benford compliance based on their dominance and magnitude.

Findings

Multiplication promotes Benford's Law adherence by increasing skewness.

Addition tends to diminish Benford conformity by producing more symmetrical distributions.

The dominance of either process depends on the magnitude and algebraic involvement in data generation.

Abstract

Benford's Law predicts that the first significant digit on the leftmost side of numbers in real-life data is proportioned between all possible 1 to 9 digits approximately as in LOG(1 + 1/digit), so that low digits occur much more frequently than high digits in the first place. The two essential prerequisites for data configuration with regards to compliance with Benford's Law are high order of magnitude and positive skewness with a tail falling to the right of the histogram, so that quantitative configuration is such that the small is numerous and the big is rare. A related topic in the study of Benford's Law is the stark contrast between multiplications and additions of random variables and their distinct resultant quantitative and digital configurations. Random multiplication processes induce substantial increase in order of magnitude and they tend to the skewed Lognormal Distribution, favoring the small over the big. Random addition processes on the other hand do not induce any increase in order of magnitude and they tend to the symmetrical Normal Distribution as predicated by the Central Limit Theorem, favoring the medium over the small and the big. Thus, while multiplication processes are highly conducive to Benford behavior, addition processes are highly detrimental to Benford behavior. In this article it is shown that often in real-life data, multiplication and addition processes mix together within one measurement or expression, and consequently they fiercely compete for dominance, each attempting to exert the greatest influence upon sizes and digits. Such tugs of war between additions and multiplications are won or lost depending on the orders of magnitude of the generating random variables, as well as on the relative strength of the two warring sides, measured in terms of the comparative arithmetical involvement in the algebraic expression of the process.