Where are the Mini Kreutz-family Comets?

TL;DR

This study investigates the brightening behavior and diversity of mini Kreutz-family comets using ground-based and space-based observations, revealing different brightening patterns, possible outbursts, and compositional differences among these small comets.

Contribution

It provides the first comprehensive analysis of pre-perihelion light-curves of mini Kreutz comets, identifying distinct brightening behaviors and potential outbursts, and suggests a different activity driver than sodium.

Findings

Kreutz comets show diverse brightening behaviors, classifiable into two types.

C/SWAN experienced a rapid brightening or outburst between 1.06 and 0.52 AU.

Kreutz comets lose mass less efficiently than C/ISON and lack certain activity-driving species.

Abstract

The Kreutz family of sungrazing comets contains over 2~000 known members, many of which are believed to be under $\sim 100$~m sizes (\textit{mini~comets}) and have only been studied at small heliocentric distances ($r_\mathrm{H}$) with space-based SOHO/STEREO spacecraft. To understand the brightening process of mini Kreutz comets, we conducted a survey using CFHT/MegaCam at moderate $r_\mathrm{H}$ guided by SOHO/STEREO observations. We identify two comets that should be in our search area but are not detected, indicating that the comets have either followed a steeper brightening rate within the previously-reported rapid brighten stage (the \textit{brightening~burst}), or the brightening burst starts earlier than expected. We present a composite analysis of pre-perihelion light-curves of five Kreutz comets that covered to $\sim 1$~AU. We observe a significant diversity in the light-curves that can be used to grossly classify them into two types: C/Ikeya-Seki and C/SWAN follow the canonical $r_\mathrm{H}^{-4}$ while the others follow $r_\mathrm{H}^{-7}$. In particular, C/SWAN seems to have undergone an outburst ($\Delta m>5$~mag) or a rapid brightening ($n\gtrsim11$) between $r_\mathrm{H}=1.06$~AU to $0.52$~AU, and shows hints of structural/compositional differences compared to other bright Kreutz comets. We also find evidence that the Kreutz comets as a population lose their mass less efficiently than the dynamically new comet, C/ISON, and are relatively devoid of species that drive C/ISON's activity at large $r_\mathrm{H}$. Concurrent observations of C/STEREO in different wavelengths also suggest that a blue-ward species such as CN may be the main driver for brightening burst instead of previously-thought sodium.