Hadron Generator and Atmospheric Seasonal Variation Influence on Cosmic Ray Ionization computed with CORSIKA Code

TL;DR

This study compares how different hadron interaction models and atmospheric conditions affect cosmic ray ionization simulations using the CORSIKA code, highlighting uncertainties and the importance of primary cosmic ray composition.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive comparison of hadron generators and atmospheric models in simulating cosmic ray induced ionization, improving understanding of model uncertainties.

Findings

Differences between hadron generators significantly affect ionization yield functions.

Atmospheric profile variations influence ion production rates.

Results align with experimental data, supporting model validity.

Abstract

Recently an essential progress in development of physical models for cosmic ray induced ionization in the atmosphere is achieved. Basically, the models are full target, i.e. based on Monte Carlo simulation of an electromagnetic-muon-nucleon cascade in the atmosphere. In general, the contribution of proton nuclei in those models is highlighted, i.e. primary cosmic ray $\alpha$-particles and heavy nuclei are neglected or scaled to protons. The development of cosmic ray induced atmospheric cascade is sensitive to the energy and mass of the primary cosmic ray particle. The largest uncertainties in Monte Carlo simulations of a cascade in the Earth atmosphere are due to assumed hadron interaction models, the so-called hadron generators. In the work presented here we compare the ionization yield functions $Y$ for primary cosmic ray nuclei, such as protons, $\alpha$-particles, Oxygen and Iron nuclei, assuming different hadron interaction models. The computations are fulfilled with the CORSIKA 6.9 code using GHEISHA 2002, FLUKA 2011, UrQMD hadron generators for energy below 80 GeV/nucleon and QGSJET II for energy above 80 GeV/nucleon. The observed difference between hadron generators is widely discussed. The influence of different atmospheric parametrizations, namely US standard atmosphere, US standard atmosphere winter and summer profiles on ion production rate is studied. Assuming realistic primary cosmic ray mass composition, the ion production rate is obtained at several rigidity cut-offs - from 1 GV (high latitudes) to 15 GV (equatorial latitudes) using various hadron generators. The computations are compared with experimental data. A conclusion concerning the consistency of the hadron generators is stated.