Should we believe the results of UV-mm galaxy SED modelling?

TL;DR

This study tests the reliability of UV-mm galaxy SED modelling using simulated galaxies, finding it generally effective but sensitive to dust extinction assumptions, thus supporting its use with some caution.

Contribution

It demonstrates the accuracy of MAGPHYS in recovering galaxy properties from synthetic data and highlights the impact of dust extinction models on SED fitting results.

Findings

MAGPHYS recovers most galaxy parameters accurately.

Results are consistent across viewing angles and time steps.

Using SMC-type dust extinction leads to larger errors.

Abstract

Galaxy spectral energy distribution (SED) modelling is a powerful tool, but constraining how well it is able to infer the true values for galaxy properties (e.g. the star formation rate, SFR) is difficult because independent determinations are often not available. However, galaxy simulations can provide a means of testing SED modelling techniques. Here, we present a numerical experiment in which we apply the SED modelling code MAGPHYS to ultraviolet (UV)--millimetre (mm) synthetic photometry generated from hydrodynamical simulations of an isolated disc galaxy and a major galaxy merger by performing three-dimensional dust radiative transfer. We compare the properties inferred from the SED modelling with the true values and find that MAGPHYS recovers most physical parameters of the simulated galaxies well. In particular, it recovers consistent parameters irrespective of the viewing angle, with smoothly varying results for neighbouring time steps of the simulation, even though each viewing angle and time step is modelled independently. The notable exception to this rule occurs when we use an SMC-type intrinsic dust extinction curve in the radiative transfer calculations. In this case, the two-component dust model used by MAGPHYS is unable to effectively correct for the attenuation of the simulated galaxies, which leads to potentially significant errors (although we obtain only marginally acceptable fits in this case). Overall, our results give confidence in the ability of SED modelling to infer physical properties of galaxies, albeit with some caveats.