Effects Of The Ionosphere On Ground-Based Detection Of The Global 21 CM Signal From The Cosmic Dawn And The Dark Ages

TL;DR

This paper investigates how Earth's dynamic ionosphere affects ground-based detection of the faint 21 cm cosmological signal, highlighting the challenges posed by flicker noise and suggesting space-based observation as a better alternative.

Contribution

First study to analyze the impact of a time-varying ionosphere on global 21 cm experiments, emphasizing calibration difficulties and proposing lunar orbit observations.

Findings

Ionospheric effects introduce flicker noise scaling as ν^{-2} in observations.

Calibration inaccuracies limit ground-based detection below 100 MHz.

Space-based observations above Earth's atmosphere are recommended for better detection.

Abstract

Detection of the global HI 21 cm signal from Cosmic Dawn and Epoch of Reionization is the key science driver for several ongoing ground-based and future ground/space-based experiments. The crucial spectral features in the global 21 cm signal (turning points) occur at low radio frequencies <100 MHz. In addition to the human-generated RFI, Earth's ionosphere drastically corrupts low-frequency radio observations from the ground. In this paper, we examine the effects of time-varying ionospheric refraction, absorption and thermal emission at these low radio frequencies and their combined effect on any ground-based global 21 cm experiment. It should be noted that this is the first study of the effect of a dynamic ionosphere on global 21 cm experiments. The fluctuations in the ionosphere are influenced by solar activity with flicker noise characteristics. The same characteristics are reflected in the ionospheric corruption to any radio signal passing through the ionosphere. As a result, any ground based observations of the faint global 21 cm signal are corrupted by flicker noise (or "$1/f$" noise, where "$f$" is the dynamical frequency) which scales as $\nu^{-2}$ (where $\nu$ is the frequency of observation) in the presence of a bright galactic foreground ($\propto \nu^{-s}$, where $s$ is radio spectral index). Hence, the calibration of the ionosphere for any such experiment is critical. Any attempt to calibrate the ionospheric effects will be subject to the inaccuracies in the current ionospheric measurements using GPS ionospheric measurements, riometer measurements, ionospheric soundings, etc. Even considering an optimistic improvement in the accuracy of GPS-TEC (Total Electron Content) measurements, we conclude that the detection of the global 21 cm signal below 100 MHz is best done from above the Earth's atmosphere in orbit of the Moon.