Sharing of Unlicensed Spectrum by Strategic Operators

TL;DR

This paper investigates how strategic wireless operators can share unlicensed spectrum efficiently using game theory, proposing static and dynamic schemes that improve revenue and coexistence, relevant for LTE-U deployment.

Contribution

It introduces a novel game-theoretic framework for spectrum sharing among strategic operators, including static and dynamic schemes with equilibrium analysis.

Findings

Static sharing scheme achieves subgame perfect Nash equilibrium.

Dynamic sharing scheme outperforms static sharing in revenue and efficiency.

Proposed schemes facilitate LTE-U deployment in unlicensed bands.

Abstract

Facing the challenge of meeting ever-increasing demand for wireless data, the industry is striving to exploit large swaths of spectrum which anyone can use for free without having to obtain a license. Major standards bodies are currently considering a proposal to retool and deploy Long Term Evolution (LTE) technologies in unlicensed bands below 6 GHz. This paper studies the fundamental questions of whether and how the unlicensed spectrum can be shared by intrinsically strategic operators without suffering from the tragedy of the commons. A class of general utility functions is considered. The spectrum sharing problem is formulated as a repeated game over a sequence of time slots. It is first shown that a simple static sharing scheme allows a given set of operators to reach a subgame perfect Nash equilibrium for mutually beneficial sharing. The question of how many operators will choose to enter the market is also addressed by studying an entry game. A sharing scheme which allows dynamic spectrum borrowing and lending between operators is then proposed to address time-varying traffic and proved to achieve perfect Bayesian equilibrium. Numerical results show that the proposed dynamic sharing scheme outperforms static sharing, which in turn achieves much higher revenue than uncoordinated full-spectrum sharing. Implications of the results to the standardization and deployment of LTE in unlicensed bands (LTE-U) are also discussed.