Small-scale Nonlinear Dynamics of K-mouflage Theories

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the small-scale nonlinear behavior of K-mouflage theories, revealing conditions for static solutions, their stability, and implications for the viability of these models at small scales.

Contribution

It provides a detailed nonlinear analysis of K-mouflage models, highlighting conditions for static solutions and their stability, which was previously unexplored.

Findings

Static solutions depend on the potential function $W_{-}(y)$.

Traveling waves propagate faster than light in these models.

Models with bounded or non-monotonic $W_{-}$ are physically inconsistent.

Abstract

We investigate the small-scale static configurations of K-mouflage models defined by a general function $K(\chi)$ of the kinetic terms. The fifth force is screened by the nonlinear K-mouflage mechanism if $K'(\chi)$ grows sufficiently fast for large negative $\chi$. In the general non-spherically symmetric case, the fifth force is not aligned with the Newtonian force. For spherically symmetric static matter density profiles, the results depend on the potential function $W_{-}(y) = y K'(-y^2/2)$, which must be monotonically increasing to $+\infty$ for $y \geq 0$ to guarantee the existence of a single solution throughout space for any matter density profile. Small radial perturbations around these static profiles propagate as traveling waves with a velocity greater than the speed of light. Starting from vanishing initial conditions for the scalar field and for a time-dependent matter density corresponding to the formation of an overdensity, we numerically check that the scalar field converges to the static solution. If $W_{-}$ is bounded, for high-density objects there are no static solutions throughout space, but one can still define a static solution restricted to large radii. Our dynamical study shows that the scalar field relaxes to this static solution at large radii, whereas spatial gradients keep growing with time at smaller radii. If $W_{-}$ is not bounded but non-monotonic, there is an infinite number of discontinuous static solutions but they are not physical and these models are not theoretically sound. Such K-mouflage scenarios provide an example of theories that can appear viable at the cosmological level, for the cosmological background and perturbative analysis, while being meaningless at a nonlinear level for small-scale configurations. This shows the importance of small-scale nonlinear analysis of screening models.