Kibble-Zurek Mechanism and Finite-Time Scaling

TL;DR

This paper enhances understanding of the Kibble-Zurek mechanism by applying finite-time scaling, clarifying defect formation during phase transitions, and analyzing the scaling behavior and critical exponents in different conditions.

Contribution

It demonstrates that finite-time scaling provides a detailed understanding of the Kibble-Zurek mechanism and clarifies the applicability of universal scaling laws in various scenarios.

Findings

FTS explains the division of adiabatic and impulse regimes.

Scaling laws are validated and improved for different observables.

Critical exponents are estimated for 2D and 3D Ising models.

Abstract

The Kibble-Zurek (KZ) mechanism has been applied to a variety of systems ranging from low temperature Bose-Einstein condensations to grand unification scales in particle physics and cosmology and from classical phase transitions to quantum phase transitions. Here we show that finite-time scaling (FTS) provides a detailed improved understanding of the mechanism. In particular, the finite time scale, which is introduced by the external driving (or quenching) and results in FTS, is the origin of the division of the adiabatic regimes from the impulse regime in the KZ mechanism. The origin of the KZ scaling for the defect density, generated during the driving through a critical point, is not that the correlation length ceases growing in the nonadiabatic impulse regime, but rather, is that it is taken over by the effective finite length scale corresponding to the finite time scale. We also show that FTS accounts well for and improves the scaling ansatz proposed recently by Liu, Polkovnikov, and Sandvik [Phys. Rev. B {\bf 89}, 054307 (2014)]. Further, we show that their universal power-law scaling form applies only to some observables in cooling but not to heating. Even in cooling, it is invalid either when an appropriate external field is present. However, this finite-time-finite-size scaling calls for caution in application of FTS. Detailed scaling behaviors of the FTS and finite-size scaling, along with their crossover, are explicitly demonstrated, with the dynamic critical exponent $z$ being estimated for two- and three-dimensional Ising models under the usual Metropolis dynamics. These values of $z$ are found to give rise to better data collapses than the extant values do in most cases but take on different values in heating and cooling in both two- and three-dimensional spaces.