The Bernardi process and torsor structures on spanning trees

TL;DR

This paper explores the Bernardi process on ribbon graphs, establishing a torsor structure on spanning trees linked to the Picard group, and shows its equivalence to rotor-routing in planar graphs, with implications for graph planarity and duality.

Contribution

It introduces a torsor structure on spanning trees via the Bernardi process and proves its equivalence to rotor-routing in planar graphs, connecting graph planarity with algebraic structures.

Findings

Bernardi bijection induces a Picard group action on spanning trees

For planar graphs, the Bernardi torsor is independent of vertex choice

Bernardi and rotor-routing torsors coincide in planar graphs

Abstract

Let G be a ribbon graph, i.e., a connected finite graph G together with a cyclic ordering of the edges around each vertex. By adapting a construction due to O. Bernardi, we associate to any pair (v,e) consisting of a vertex v and an edge e adjacent to v a bijection between spanning trees of G and elements of the set Pic^g(G) of degree g divisor classes on G, where g is the genus of G. Using the natural action of the Picard group Pic^0(G) on Pic^g(G), we show that the Bernardi bijection gives rise to a simply transitive action \beta_v of Pic^0(G) on the set of spanning trees which does not depend on the choice of e. A plane graph has a natural ribbon structure (coming from the counterclockwise orientation of the plane), and in this case we show that \beta_v is independent of v as well. Thus for plane graphs, the set of spanning trees is naturally a torsor for the Picard group. Conversely, we show that if \beta_v is independent of v then G together with its ribbon structure is planar. We also show that the natural action of Pic^0(G) on spanning trees of a plane graph is compatible with planar duality. These findings are formally quite similar to results of Holroyd et al. and Chan-Church-Grochow, who used rotor-routing to construct an action r_v of Pic^0(G) on the spanning trees of a ribbon graph G, which they show is independent of v if and only if G is planar. It is therefore natural to ask how the two constructions are related. We prove that \beta_v = r_v for all vertices v of G when G is a planar ribbon graph, i.e. the two torsor structures (Bernardi and rotor-routing) on the set of spanning trees coincide. In particular, it follows that the rotor-routing torsor is compatible with planar duality. We conjecture that for every non-planar ribbon graph G, there exists a vertex v with \beta_v \neq r_v.