Disruption of co-orbital (1:1) planetary resonances during gas-driven orbital migration

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that gas-driven orbital migration in protoplanetary disks disrupts co-orbital planetary resonances, explaining the absence of observed co-orbital systems in Kepler data, especially for planets in the super-Earth to Saturn mass range.

Contribution

The paper reveals a mechanism by which co-orbital resonances are destabilized during migration due to gap formation, a novel insight into planetary system evolution.

Findings

Co-orbital systems are disrupted during large-scale migration.

Gap formation alters disk torques, breaking resonance.

Disruption occurs for planets with masses near the gap-opening threshold.

Abstract

Planets close to their stars are thought to form farther out and migrate inward due to angular momentum exchange with gaseous protoplanetary disks. This process can produce systems of planets in co-orbital (Trojan or 1:1) resonance, in which two planets share the same orbit, usually separated by 60 degrees. Co-orbital systems are detectable among the planetary systems found by the Kepler mission either directly or by transit timing variations. However, no co-orbital systems have been found within the thousands of Kepler planets and candidates. Here we study the orbital evolution of co-orbital planets embedded in a protoplanetary disk using a grid-based hydrodynamics code. We show that pairs of similar-mass planets in co-orbital resonance are disrupted during large-scale orbital migration. Destabilization occurs when one or both planets is near the critical mass needed to open a gap in the gaseous disk. A confined gap is opened that spans the 60 degree azimuthal separation between planets. This alters the torques imparted by the disk on each planet -- pushing the leading planet outward and the trailing planet inward -- and disrupts the resonance. The mechanism applies to systems in which the two planets' masses differ by a factor of two or less. In a simple flared disk model the critical mass for gap opening varies from a few Earth masses at the inner edge of the disk to 1 Saturn-mass at 5 AU. A pair of co-orbital planets with masses in this range that migrates will enter a region where the planets are at the gap-opening limit. At that point the resonance is disrupted. We therefore predict an absence of planets on co-orbital configurations with masses in the super-Earth to Saturn mass range with similar masses.