Radial Velocities of Stars with Multiple Co-orbital Planets

TL;DR

This paper investigates the detection challenges and dynamical stability of co-orbital multi-planet systems, highlighting how such configurations can evade current detection methods and affect mass estimates.

Contribution

It provides a theoretical analysis of the stability and observational signatures of co-orbital planets, emphasizing their potential to be overlooked or misinterpreted in exoplanet surveys.

Findings

Equally spaced co-orbital planets produce no radial velocity signal.

Lopsided co-orbital systems generate detectable but misleading signals.

Co-orbital configurations can significantly impact exoplanet mass and density estimates.

Abstract

To date, well over a thousand planets have been discovered orbiting other stars, hundreds of them in multi-planet systems. Most of these exoplanets have been detected by either the transit method or the radial velocity method, rather than by other methods such as astrometry or direct imaging. Both the radial velocity and astrometric methods rely upon the reflex motion of the parent star induced by the gravitational attraction of its planets. However, this reflex motion is subject to misinterpretation when a star has two or more planets with the same orbital period. Such co-orbital planets may effectively "hide" from detection by current algorithms. In principle, any number of planets can share the same orbit; the case where they all have the same mass has been studied most. Salo and Yoder (A & A 205, 309--327, 1988) have shown that more than 8 planets of equal mass sharing a circular orbit must be equally spaced for dynamical stability, while fewer than 7 equal-mass planets are stable only in a configuration where all of the planets remain on the same side of their parent star. For 7 or 8 equal-mass planets, both configurations are stable. By symmetry, it is clear that the equally-spaced systems produce no reflex motion or radial velocity signal at all in their parent stars. This could lead to their being overlooked entirely, unless they happen to be detected by the transit method. It is equally clear that the lopsided systems produce a greater radial velocity signal than a single such planet would, but a smaller signal than if all of the planets were combined into one. This could seriously mislead estimates of exoplanet masses and densities. Transit data and ellipsoidal (tidal) brightness variations in such systems also are subject to misinterpretation. This behavior is also representative of more natural systems, with co-orbital planets of different masses.