Could Jean-Dominique Cassini see the famous division in Saturn's rings?

TL;DR

This study investigates whether Jean-Dominique Cassini could have observed the division in Saturn's rings using the optical lenses he had in the 17th century, combining historical analysis with optical simulations.

Contribution

The paper combines historical lens analysis with optical simulations to assess Cassini's observational capabilities of Saturn's ring division.

Findings

Cassini's lenses had high optical quality with Strehl ratios above 0.8.

Simulations suggest Cassini could have observed the ring division.

Optical quality and atmospheric conditions support historical observations.

Abstract

Nowadays, astronomers want to observe gaps in exozodiacal disks to confirm the presence of exoplanets, or even make actual images of these companions. Four hundred and fifty years ago, Jean-Dominique Cassini did a similar study on a closer object: Saturn. After joining the newly created Observatoire de Paris in 1671, he discovered 4 of Saturn's satellites (Iapetus, Rhea, Tethys and Dione), and also the gap in its rings. He made these discoveries observing through the best optics at the time, made in Italy by famous opticians like Giuseppe Campani or Eustachio Divini. But was he really able to observe this black line in Saturn's rings? That is what a team of optical scientists from Observatoire de Paris - LESIA with the help of Onera and Institut d'Optique tried to find out, analyzing the lenses used by Cassini, and still preserved in the collection of the observatory. The main difficulty was that even if the lenses have diameters between 84 and 239 mm, the focal lengths are between 6 and 50 m, more than the focal lengths of the primary mirrors of future ELTs. The analysis shows that the lenses have an exceptionally good quality, with a wavefront error of approximately 50 nm rms and 200 nm peak-to-valley, leading to Strehl ratios higher than 0.8. Taking into account the chromaticity of the glass, the wavefront quality and atmospheric turbulence, reconstructions of his observations tend to show that he was actually able to see the division named after him.