Jacob's Ladder and Scientific Ontologies

TL;DR

This paper explores how a constructivist epistemological framework, combining Piaget's ideas and Bayesian methods, can address knowledge construction, exemplified through historical chemistry episodes and the concept of eigen-solutions.

Contribution

It introduces a novel epistemological approach integrating cognitive constructivism, von Foerster's metaphor, and Bayesian inference to analyze scientific ontologies and knowledge re-equilibration.

Findings

Illustrates the framework with historical chemistry cases

Provides guidelines for scientific development and argumentation

Connects epistemology with formal Bayesian methods

Abstract

The main goal of this article is to use the epistemological framework of a specific version of Cognitive Constructivism to address Piaget's central problem of knowledge construction, namely, the re-equilibration of cognitive structures. The distinctive objective character of this constructivist framework is based on Heinz von Foerster's fundamental metaphor of - objects as tokens for eigen-solutions, and is also supported by formal inference methods of Bayesian statistics. This epistemological perspective is illustrated using some episodes in the history of chemistry concerning the definition or identification of chemical elements. Some of von Foerster's epistemological imperatives provide general guidelines of development and argumentation.