Comment on "Parametric amplification in Josephson junction embedded transmission lines"

TL;DR

This paper corrects a mathematical error in previous work on Josephson junction transmission lines, clarifying that exponential parametric gain is only achievable with specific dispersion conditions, not universally as previously claimed.

Contribution

It identifies and corrects a derivation error in prior theoretical analysis, providing the accurate expression for parametric gain in nonlinear Josephson transmission lines.

Findings

Exponential gain requires specific dispersion conditions.

Quadratic gain can occur around the pump frequency.

Corrected gain expression invalidates previous universal claims.

Abstract

Recently Yaakobi and co-workers [Phys. Rev. B 87, 144301 (2013)] theoretically studied four-wave mixing and parametric amplification in a nonlinear transmission line consisting of capacitively shunted Josephson junctions. By deriving and solving the coupled-mode equations, they have arrived at the conclusion that in a wide frequency range around the pump frequency exponential parametric gain (in which the signal grows exponentially with distance) can be achieved. However, we have found a mathematical error in their derivation of the coupled-mode equations (Equation (A13)), which leads to the wrong expression of the gain factor and invalidates their conclusions on the gain and bandwidth. In this comment, we present the correct expression for the parametric gain. We show that for a transmission line with weak dispersion or positive dispersion ($\Delta k>0 $), as is the case discussed by Yaakobi et al, while quadratic (power) gain can occur around the pump frequency, exponential gain is impossible. Furthermore, for a transmission line with proper intrinsic or engineered dispersion, exponential gain occurs at frequencies where the phase matching condition is met, while around the pump frequency the gain is still quadratic.