Depth-4 Lower Bounds, Determinantal Complexity : A Unified Approach

TL;DR

This paper introduces a unified combinatorial approach to establish depth-4 circuit lower bounds for explicit polynomials in VP and VNP, and compares these bounds with determinantal complexity results, notably for iterated matrix multiplication.

Contribution

It identifies a simple combinatorial property that yields depth-4 circuit lower bounds for any polynomial satisfying it, regardless of class, and proves new lower bounds for determinantal complexity of iterated matrix multiplication.

Findings

Depth-4 circuit lower bounds of 2^{Ω(√n log n)} for certain explicit polynomials.

Determinantal complexity of iterated matrix multiplication is Ω(dn), matching known bounds for d=n.

Unified analysis simplifies understanding of lower bounds across different polynomial classes.

Abstract

Tavenas has recently proved that any n^{O(1)}-variate and degree n polynomial in VP can be computed by a depth-4 circuit of size 2^{O(\sqrt{n}\log n)}. So to prove VP not equal to VNP, it is sufficient to show that an explicit polynomial in VNP of degree n requires 2^{\omega(\sqrt{n}\log n)} size depth-4 circuits. Soon after Tavenas's result, for two different explicit polynomials, depth-4 circuit size lower bounds of 2^{\Omega(\sqrt{n}\log n)} have been proved Kayal et al. and Fournier et al. In particular, using combinatorial design Kayal et al.\ construct an explicit polynomial in VNP that requires depth-4 circuits of size 2^{\Omega(\sqrt{n}\log n)} and Fournier et al.\ show that iterated matrix multiplication polynomial (which is in VP) also requires 2^{\Omega(\sqrt{n}\log n)} size depth-4 circuits. In this paper, we identify a simple combinatorial property such that any polynomial f that satisfies the property would achieve similar circuit size lower bound for depth-4 circuits. In particular, it does not matter whether f is in VP or in VNP. As a result, we get a very simple unified lower bound analysis for the above mentioned polynomials. Another goal of this paper is to compare between our current knowledge of depth-4 circuit size lower bounds and determinantal complexity lower bounds. We prove the that the determinantal complexity of iterated matrix multiplication polynomial is \Omega(dn) where d is the number of matrices and n is the dimension of the matrices. So for d=n, we get that the iterated matrix multiplication polynomial achieves the current best known lower bounds in both fronts: depth-4 circuit size and determinantal complexity. To the best of our knowledge, a \Theta(n) bound for the determinantal complexity for the iterated matrix multiplication polynomial was known only for constant d>1 by Jansen.