Reconciling 56Ni Production in Type Ia Supernovae with Double Degenerate Scenarios

TL;DR

This paper investigates how different double degenerate scenarios for Type Ia supernovae can produce the observed nickel-56 yields, by comparing theoretical models with observed white dwarf populations and supernova characteristics.

Contribution

It combines observational data, models, and simulations to estimate the WD masses needed in collision and merger scenarios to match observed supernova properties.

Findings

Collisions require WD components to be around 0.75Msun, higher than typical WD masses.

Sub-Chandrasekhar detonations need WDs near 1.1Msun, similar to the average binary mass sum.

High-mass WDs are necessary for certain explosion mechanisms, implying specific progenitor evolution paths.

Abstract

Binary white dwarf (WD) coalescences driven by gravitational waves or collisions in triple systems are potential progenitors of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia). We combine the distribution of 56Ni inferred from observations of SNe Ia with the results of both sub-Chandrasekhar detonation models and direct collision calculations to estimate what mass WDs should be exploding in each scenario to reproduce the observations. These WD mass distributions are then compared with the observed Galactic WD mass distribution and Monte Carlo simulations of WD-WD binary populations. For collisions, we find that the average mass of the individual components of the WD-WD binary must be peaked at ~0.75Msun, significantly higher than the average WD mass in binaries or in the field of ~0.55-0.60Msun. Thus, if collisions produce a large fraction of SNe Ia, then a mechanism must exist that favors large mass WDs. On the other hand, in an old stellar population, collisions would naturally result in a class of low luminosity SNe Ia, and we suggest these may be related to 1991bg-like events. For sub-Chandrasekhar detonations, we find that the average mass of the exploding WDs must be peaked at ~1.1Msun. This is interestingly similar to the average sum of the masses in WD-WD binaries, but it is not clear (and should be further explored) whether double degenerate mergers would be sufficiently efficient at synthesizing 56Ni to match the observed yields. If not, then actual ~1.1Msun WDs would be needed for sub-Chandrasekhar detonations. Since such high mass WDs are produced relatively quickly in comparison to the age of the environments where SNe Ia are found, this would require either accretion onto lower mass WDs prior to ignition or a long timescale between formation of the ~1.1Msun WD and ignition (such as set by gravitational wave emission or binary interactions).