Reply to the comment on "Exact Expression for Radiation of an Accelerated Charge in Classical Electrodynamics"

TL;DR

This paper critiques a recent comment on electromagnetic radiation from accelerated charges, highlighting flaws in the accepted formulation and proposing an experiment to test its validity.

Contribution

It identifies issues in the current understanding of radiation from accelerated charges and clarifies misunderstandings about radiated power measurement.

Findings

Current formulation violates energy conservation principles

Misinterpretation of radiated power crossing a sphere

Proposes an experiment to test the accepted theory

Abstract

Flaws and ambiguities are pointed out upon examining the comment attempting to solve a problem as raised recently --- the currently accepted formulation of electromagnetic radiation of an accelerated charge violates the principle of conservation of energy. This problem is not solved by the comment, due to a misunderstanding in the meaning of the total radiated power crossing a sphere. An experiment is suggested to determine whether on not the currently accepted formulation is valid.