Growth Index after the Planck Results

TL;DR

This study analyzes the growth index using redshift-space distortion data to test deviations from the standard $ ext{Lambda}$CDM model and Einstein's gravity, finding slight deviations in Einstein's gravity but consistency with modified gravity.

Contribution

It provides updated constraints on the growth index $oldsymbol{\gamma_L}$ within Einstein's and modified gravity theories using recent cosmic observations and MCMC analysis.

Findings

Growth index $oldsymbol{\gamma_L}$ deviates from $oldsymbol{6/11}$ in Einstein's gravity.

No significant deviation from Einstein's relativity in modified gravity models.

Current data do not favor modifications beyond $ ext{Lambda}$CDM}$ under Einstein's gravity.

Abstract

The growth index $\gamma_L$ was proposed to investigate the possible deviation from the standard $\Lambda$CDM model and Einstein's gravity theory in a dynamical perspective. Recently, thanks to the measurement of the cosmic growth rate via the redshift-space distortion, one can understand the evolution of density contrast through $f\sigma_8(z)$, where $f(z)=d\ln \delta/d \ln a$ is the growth rate of matter and $\sigma_8(z)$ is the rms amplitude of the density contrast $\delta$ at the comoving $8h^{-1}$ Mpc scale. In this paper, we use the redshift space distortion data points to study the growth index on the bases of Einstein's gravity theory and a modified gravity theory under the assumption of $f=\Omega_m(a)^{\gamma_L}$. The cosmic background evolution is fixed by the cosmic observations from the type Ia supernovae SNLS3, cosmic microwave background radiation data from {\it Planck} and baryon acoustic oscillations. Via the Markov Chain Monte Carlo method, we found the $\gamma_L$ values for Einstein's gravity with a cosmological constant, $w=constant$ dark energy and a modified gravity theory in the $1,2,3\sigma$ regions respectively: $0.675_{-0.0662-0.120-0.155}^{+0.0611+0.129+0.178}$, $0.745_{-0.0819-0.146-0.190}^{+0.0755+0.157+0.205}$ and $0.555_{-0.0167-0.0373-0.0516}^{+0.0193+0.0335+0.0436}$. In the Einstein's gravity theory, the values of growth index $\gamma_L$ show almost $2\sigma$ deviation from the theoretical prediction 6/11 for the $\Lambda$CDM model. However in the modified gravity framework, a deviation from the Einstein's relativity is not detected in $1\sigma$ region. That implies that the currently available cosmic observations don't expect an alternative modified gravity theory beyond the $\Lambda$CDM model under Einstein's gravity, but that the simple assumption of $f=\Omega_m^{\gamma_L}$ should be improved.