Action Research Can Swing the Balance in Experimental Software Engineering

TL;DR

This paper discusses how Action Research can enhance experimental studies in Software Engineering by providing in-depth insights and practical evidence, demonstrated through a study on code refactoring decisions in distributed teams.

Contribution

It introduces Action Research as a valuable approach for conducting meaningful experimental studies in Software Engineering, with practical guidance and an illustrative in vivo study.

Findings

Action Research offers valuable insights into software development practices.

The in vivo study revealed subjective decision factors in code refactoring.

Guidance provided for conducting Action Research in Software Engineering.

Abstract

In general, professionals still ignore scientific evidence in place of expert opinions in most of their decision-making. For this reason, it is still common to see the adoption of new software technologies in the field without any scientific basis or well-grounded criteria, but on the opinions of experts. Experimental Software Engineering is of paramount importance to provide the foundations to understand the limits and applicability of software technologies. The need to better observe and understand the practice of Software Engineering leads us to look for alternative experimental approaches to support our studies. Different research strategies can be used to explore different Software Engineering practices. Action Research can be seen as one alternative to intensify the conducting of important experimental studies with results of great value while investigating the Software Engineering practices in depth. In this paper, a discussion on the use of Action Research in Software Engineering is presented. Aiming at better explaining the application of Action Research, an experimental study (in vivo) on the investigation of the subjective decisions of software developers, concerned with the refactoring of source code to improve source code quality in a distributed software development context is depicted. In addition, some guidance on how to accomplish an Action Research study in Software Engineering supplement the discussions.