The Influence of Dark Matter Halos on Dynamical Estimates of Black Hole Mass: Ten New Measurements for High-sigma Early-Type Galaxies

TL;DR

This study presents ten new high-mass black hole measurements in early-type galaxies, examining how dark matter halos influence dynamical estimates and comparing results to existing black hole scaling relations.

Contribution

It provides new black hole mass measurements and analyzes the impact of dark matter halos on dynamical modeling, clarifying when dark matter can be neglected.

Findings

Dark matter inclusion affects stellar mass-to-light ratios.

Black holes are more massive than predicted by previous relations.

Massive black holes are more common than earlier estimates suggested.

Abstract

Adaptive-Optics assisted SINFONI observations of the central regions of ten early-type galaxies are presented. Based primarily on the SINFONI kinematics, ten black hole masses occupying the high-mass regime of the M_BH-sigma relation are derived using three-integral Schwarzschild models. The effect of dark matter inclusion on the black hole mass is explored. The omission of a dark matter halo in the model results in a higher stellar mass-to-light ratio, especially when extensive kinematic data are used in the model. However, when the diameter of the sphere of influence -- computed using the black hole mass derived without a dark halo -- is at least 10 times the PSF FWHM during the observations, it is safe to exclude a dark matter component in the dynamical modeling, i.e. the change in black hole mass is negligible. When the spatial resolution is marginal, restricting the mass-to-light ratio to the right value returns the correct M_BH although dark halo is not present in the model. Compared to the M_BH-sigma and M_BH-L relations of McConnell et al. (2011), the ten black holes are all more massive than expected from the luminosities and seven black hole masses are higher than expected from the stellar velocity dispersions of the host bulges. Using new fitted relations which include the ten galaxies, we find that the space density of the most massive black holes (M_BH >~ 10^9 Msun) estimated from the M_BH-L relation is higher than the estimate based on the M_BH-sigma relation and the latter is higher than model predictions based on quasar counts, each by about an order of magnitude.