Bilu-Linial Stable Instances of Max Cut and Minimum Multiway Cut

TL;DR

This paper develops a polynomial-time algorithm for gamma-stable Max Cut instances with gamma above a certain threshold, using semidefinite programming, and explores the limits of tractability and stability in Max Cut and Multiway Cut problems.

Contribution

It introduces a robust algorithm for gamma-stable Max Cut instances and establishes bounds on stability levels where the problem remains tractable or becomes hard, improving previous results.

Findings

Algorithm works for gamma >= c*sqrt(log n)*log log n

SDP relaxation is integral for gamma >= D_{l2^2→l1}(n)

No tractable relaxation for gamma < alpha_{SC}(n/2)

Abstract

We investigate the notion of stability proposed by Bilu and Linial. We obtain an exact polynomial-time algorithm for $\gamma$-stable Max Cut instances with $\gamma \geq c\sqrt{\log n}\log\log n$ for some absolute constant $c > 0$. Our algorithm is robust: it never returns an incorrect answer; if the instance is $\gamma$-stable, it finds the maximum cut, otherwise, it either finds the maximum cut or certifies that the instance is not $\gamma$-stable. We prove that there is no robust polynomial-time algorithm for $\gamma$-stable instances of Max Cut when $\gamma < \alpha_{SC}(n/2)$, where $\alpha_{SC}$ is the best approximation factor for Sparsest Cut with non-uniform demands. Our algorithm is based on semidefinite programming. We show that the standard SDP relaxation for Max Cut (with $\ell_2^2$ triangle inequalities) is integral if $\gamma \geq D_{\ell_2^2\to \ell_1}(n)$, where $D_{\ell_2^2\to \ell_1}(n)$ is the least distortion with which every $n$ point metric space of negative type embeds into $\ell_1$. On the negative side, we show that the SDP relaxation is not integral when $\gamma < D_{\ell_2^2\to \ell_1}(n/2)$. Moreover, there is no tractable convex relaxation for $\gamma$-stable instances of Max Cut when $\gamma < \alpha_{SC}(n/2)$. That suggests that solving $\gamma$-stable instances with $\gamma =o(\sqrt{\log n})$ might be difficult or impossible. Our results significantly improve previously known results. The best previously known algorithm for $\gamma$-stable instances of Max Cut required that $\gamma \geq c\sqrt{n}$ (for some $c > 0$) [Bilu, Daniely, Linial, and Saks]. No hardness results were known for the problem. Additionally, we present an algorithm for 4-stable instances of Minimum Multiway Cut. We also study a relaxed notion of weak stability.