Brinicles as a case of inverse chemical gardens

TL;DR

Brinicles are natural ice tubes formed by a process similar to chemical gardens, involving osmotic pressure and freezing, representing an inverse form of these self-assembled structures.

Contribution

This paper demonstrates that brinicles can be understood as inverse chemical gardens, linking natural ice formation to self-assembled tubular precipitation structures.

Findings

Brinicles form through osmotic pressure-driven freezing in polar seas.

They are analogous to chemical gardens but grow downwards as inverse structures.

The process involves a siphon pump mechanism driven by freezing and brine drainage.

Abstract

Brinicles are hollow tubes of ice from centimetres to metres in length that form under floating sea ice in the polar oceans when dense, cold brine drains downwards from sea ice into sea water close to its freezing point. When this extremely cold brine leaves the ice it freezes the water it comes into contact with; a hollow tube of ice --- a brinicle --- growing downwards around the plume of descending brine. We show that brinicles can be understood as a form of the self-assembled tubular precipitation structures termed chemical gardens, plant-like structures formed on placing together a soluble metal salt, often in the form of a seed crystal, and an aqueous solution of one of many anions, often silicate. On one hand, in the case of classical chemical gardens, an osmotic pressure difference across a semipermeable precipitation membrane that filters solutions by rejecting the solute leads to an inflow of water and to its rupture. The internal solution, generally being lighter than the external solution, flows up through the break, and as it does so a tube grows upwards by precipitation around the jet of internal solution. Such chemical-garden tubes can grow to many centimetres in length. In the case of brinicles, on the other hand, in floating sea ice we have porous ice in a mushy layer that filters out water, by freezing it, and allows concentrated brine through. Again there is an osmotic pressure difference leading to a continuing ingress of sea water in a siphon pump mechanism that is sustained as long as the ice continues to freeze. Since the brine that is pumped out is denser than the sea water, and descends rather rises, a brinicle is a downwards growing tube of ice; an inverse chemical garden.