The temperatures of Red Supergiants

TL;DR

This study re-evaluates Red Supergiants' temperatures using spectral energy distributions, finding they are warmer than previously believed, which impacts stellar evolution models and supernova progenitor understanding.

Contribution

The paper introduces a new method for determining RSG temperatures using SED fitting, revealing higher temperatures than those derived from TiO band analysis, and discusses implications for stellar evolution.

Findings

TiO-based temperatures are systematically lower than SED-based temperatures.

TiO fits over-predict near-IR flux and suggest anomalously low extinctions.

RSGs are warmer than previously estimated, affecting evolutionary models.

Abstract

We present a re-appraisal of the temperatures of Red Supergiants (RSGs) using their optical and near-infrared spectral energy distributions (SEDs). We have obtained data of a sample of RSGs in the Magellanic Clouds using VLT+XSHOOTER, and we fit MARCS model atmospheres to different regions of the spectra, deriving effective temperatures for each star from (a) the TiO bands, (b) line-free continuum regions of the spectral energy distributions (SEDs), and (c) the integrated fluxes. We show that the temperatures derived from fits to the TiO bands are systematically {\it lower} than the other two methods by several hundred Kelvin. The TiO fits also dramatically over-predict the flux in the near-IR, and imply extinctions which are anomalously low compared to neighbouring stars. In contrast, the SED temperatures provide good fits to the fluxes at all wavelengths other than the TiO bands, are in agreement with the temperatures from the flux integration method, and imply extinctions consistent with nearby stars. After considering a number of ways to reconcile this discrepancy, we conclude that 3-D effects (i.e.\ granulation) are the most likely cause, as they affect the temperature structure in the upper layers where the TiO lines form. The continuum, however, which forms at much deeper layers, is apparently more robust to such effects. We therefore conclude that RSG temperatures are much warmer than previously thought. We discuss the implications of this result for stellar evolution and supernova progenitors, and provide relations to determine the bolometric luminosities of RSGs from single-band photometry.