The Asymptotic Giant Branches of GCs: Selective Entry Only

TL;DR

This study provides direct observational evidence that only a subset of stars in globular clusters evolve through the AGB phase, revealing a deficiency of CN-strong stars on the AGB and challenging existing stellar evolution models.

Contribution

It offers the first direct confirmation that AGB evolution is limited to certain stars in globular clusters, based on spectroscopic analysis of multiple clusters.

Findings

Deficiency of CN-strong stars on the AGB in GCs

Only a subset of stars in GCs undergo AGB evolution

Confirmation of selective AGB entry through sodium abundance measurements

Abstract

The handful of available observations of AGB stars in Galactic Globular Clusters suggest that the GC AGB populations are dominated by cyanogen-weak stars. This contrasts strongly with the distributions in the RGB (and other) populations, which generally show a 50:50 bimodality in CN band strength. If it is true that the AGB populations show very different distributions then it presents a serious problem for low mass stellar evolution theory, since such a surface abundance change going from the RGB to AGB is not predicted by stellar models. However this is only a tentative conclusion, since it is based on very small AGB sample sizes. To test whether this problem really exists we have carried out an observational campaign specifically targeting AGB stars in GCs. We have obtained medium resolution spectra for about 250 AGB stars across 9 Galactic GCs using the multi-object spectrograph on the AAT (2df/AAOmega). We present some of the preliminary findings of the study for the second parameter trio of GCs: NGC 288, NGC 362 and NGC 1851. The results indeed show that there is a deficiency of stars with strong CN bands on the AGB. To confirm that this phenomenon is robust and not just confined to CN band strengths and their vagaries, we have made observations using FLAMES/VLT to measure elemental abundances for NGC 6752.We present some initial results from this study also. Our sodium abundance results show conclusively that only a subset of stars in GCs experience the AGB phase of evolution. This is the first direct, concrete confirmation of the phenomenon.