Nuclear Thermometers for Classical Novae

TL;DR

This study evaluates elemental abundance ratios as reliable thermometers for peak temperatures in classical novae, analyzing their robustness against nuclear physics uncertainties and comparing model predictions with observations.

Contribution

It identifies the most effective elemental ratios for temperature diagnostics in neon novae and assesses their sensitivity to nuclear reaction rate uncertainties.

Findings

N/O, N/Al, O/Na, Na/Al are robust temperature indicators.

O/S, S/Al, O/P, P/Al ratios are highly sensitive to reaction rate uncertainties.

Estimated white dwarf masses range from 1.18 to 1.35 solar masses.

Abstract

Classical novae are stellar explosions occurring in binary systems, consisting of a white dwarf and a main sequence companion. Thermonuclear runaways on the surface of massive white dwarfs, consisting of oxygen and neon, are believed to reach peak temperatures of several hundred million kelvin. These temperatures are strongly correlated with the underlying white dwarf mass. The observational counterparts of such models are likely associated with outbursts that show strong spectral lines of neon in their shells (neon novae). The goals of this work are to investigate how useful elemental abundances are for constraining the peak temperatures achieved during these outbursts and determine how robust "nova thermometers" are with respect to uncertain nuclear physics input. We present updated observed abundances in neon novae and perform a series of hydrodynamic simulations for several white dwarf masses. We find that the most useful thermometers, N/O, N/Al, O/S, S/Al, O/Na, Na/Al, O/P, and P/Al, are those with the steepest monotonic dependence on peak temperature. The sensitivity of these thermometers to thermonuclear reaction rate variations is explored using post-processing nucleosynthesis simulations. The ratios N/O, N/Al, O/Na, and Na/Al are robust, meaning they are minimally affected by uncertain rates. However, their dependence on peak temperature is relatively weak. The ratios O/S, S/Al, O/P, and P/Al reveal strong dependences on temperature and the poorly known 30P(p,g)31S rate. We compare our model predictions to neon nova observations and obtain the following estimates for the underlying white dwarf masses: 1.34-1.35 solar masses (V838 Her), 1.18-1.21 solar masses (V382 Vel), <1.3 solar masses (V693 CrA), <1.2 solar masses (LMC 1990#1), and <1.2 solar masses (QU Vul).