Hypothesis Testing in Feedforward Networks with Broadcast Failures

TL;DR

This paper investigates the conditions under which a network of nodes can reliably determine an underlying truth through sequential hypothesis testing despite broadcast failures modeled as erasures or flips, revealing the importance of network connectivity and error rates.

Contribution

It establishes that unbounded connectivity enables convergence to the true hypothesis even with high erasure probabilities, and characterizes convergence conditions under symmetric channel errors.

Findings

Convergence fails with bounded predecessor learning.

Unbounded predecessor learning ensures convergence despite erasures.

Necessary conditions for convergence when flipping probabilities approach 1/2.

Abstract

Consider a countably infinite set of nodes, which sequentially make decisions between two given hypotheses. Each node takes a measurement of the underlying truth, observes the decisions from some immediate predecessors, and makes a decision between the given hypotheses. We consider two classes of broadcast failures: 1) each node broadcasts a decision to the other nodes, subject to random erasure in the form of a binary erasure channel; 2) each node broadcasts a randomly flipped decision to the other nodes in the form of a binary symmetric channel. We are interested in whether there exists a decision strategy consisting of a sequence of likelihood ratio tests such that the node decisions converge in probability to the underlying truth. In both cases, we show that if each node only learns from a bounded number of immediate predecessors, then there does not exist a decision strategy such that the decisions converge in probability to the underlying truth. However, in case 1, we show that if each node learns from an unboundedly growing number of predecessors, then the decisions converge in probability to the underlying truth, even when the erasure probabilities converge to 1. We also derive the convergence rate of the error probability. In case 2, we show that if each node learns from all of its previous predecessors, then the decisions converge in probability to the underlying truth when the flipping probabilities of the binary symmetric channels are bounded away from 1/2. In the case where the flipping probabilities converge to 1/2, we derive a necessary condition on the convergence rate of the flipping probabilities such that the decisions still converge to the underlying truth. We also explicitly characterize the relationship between the convergence rate of the error probability and the convergence rate of the flipping probabilities.