Leveraging Subjective Human Annotation for Clustering Historic Newspaper Articles

TL;DR

This paper investigates automatic categorization of historic newspaper articles using subjective human annotations, employing unsupervised and semi-supervised learning to improve searchability in large archives.

Contribution

It introduces a novel approach that incorporates subjective human annotations into clustering algorithms for better newspaper article categorization.

Findings

Subjectivity in categorization tasks was confirmed through a pilot study.

Semi-supervised clustering algorithms effectively handled subjective labels.

The BODHI system facilitates user correction and tagging, aiding future annotation efforts.

Abstract

The New York Public Library is participating in the Chronicling America initiative to develop an online searchable database of historically significant newspaper articles. Microfilm copies of the newspapers are scanned and high resolution Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software is run on them. The text from the OCR provides a wealth of data and opinion for researchers and historians. However, categorization of articles provided by the OCR engine is rudimentary and a large number of the articles are labeled editorial without further grouping. Manually sorting articles into fine-grained categories is time consuming if not impossible given the size of the corpus. This paper studies techniques for automatic categorization of newspaper articles so as to enhance search and retrieval on the archive. We explore unsupervised (e.g. KMeans) and semi-supervised (e.g. constrained clustering) learning algorithms to develop article categorization schemes geared towards the needs of end-users. A pilot study was designed to understand whether there was unanimous agreement amongst patrons regarding how articles can be categorized. It was found that the task was very subjective and consequently automated algorithms that could deal with subjective labels were used. While the small scale pilot study was extremely helpful in designing machine learning algorithms, a much larger system needs to be developed to collect annotations from users of the archive. The "BODHI" system currently being developed is a step in that direction, allowing users to correct wrongly scanned OCR and providing keywords and tags for newspaper articles used frequently. On successful implementation of the beta version of this system, we hope that it can be integrated with existing software being developed for the Chronicling America project.