Hidden breakpoints in genome alignments

TL;DR

This paper extends the multichromosomal breakpoint median problem to include gene gain and loss, providing a method to estimate hidden breakpoints in genome evolution and analyzing the impact of alignment errors.

Contribution

It introduces a new approach to detect hidden breakpoints considering gene gain/loss and improves understanding of alignment errors in genome comparisons.

Findings

Hidden breakpoints depend on inversion and gene gain/loss rates.

Current aligners introduce significant errors in hidden breakpoint estimation.

Error in hidden breakpoint detection increases with evolutionary distance.

Abstract

During the course of evolution, an organism's genome can undergo changes that affect the large-scale structure of the genome. These changes include gene gain, loss, duplication, chromosome fusion, fission, and rearrangement. When gene gain and loss occurs in addition to other types of rearrangement, breakpoints of rearrangement can exist that are only detectable by comparison of three or more genomes. An arbitrarily large number of these "hidden" breakpoints can exist among genomes that exhibit no rearrangements in pairwise comparisons. We present an extension of the multichromosomal breakpoint median problem to genomes that have undergone gene gain and loss. We then demonstrate that the median distance among three genomes can be used to calculate a lower bound on the number of hidden breakpoints present. We provide an implementation of this calculation including the median distance, along with some practical improvements on the time complexity of the underlying algorithm. We apply our approach to measure the abundance of hidden breakpoints in simulated data sets under a wide range of evolutionary scenarios. We demonstrate that in simulations the hidden breakpoint counts depend strongly on relative rates of inversion and gene gain/loss. Finally we apply current multiple genome aligners to the simulated genomes, and show that all aligners introduce a high degree of error in hidden breakpoint counts, and that this error grows with evolutionary distance in the simulation. Our results suggest that hidden breakpoint error may be pervasive in genome alignments.