Whence the Minkowski Momentum?

TL;DR

This paper explores the nature of electromagnetic momentum, contrasting Abraham and Minkowski formulations, and analyzes how impedance mismatch influences radiation pressure measurements involving absorptive or reflective media.

Contribution

It clarifies the conditions under which Minkowski momentum appears in experiments, emphasizing the role of impedance mismatch in submerged media.

Findings

Minkowski momentum arises due to impedance mismatch effects.

Absorptive media experience forces partly from absorbed Abraham momentum.

The paper distinguishes between Abraham and Minkowski momentum contributions.

Abstract

Electromagnetic waves carry the Abraham momentum, whose density is given by p_EM = S(r,t)/c^2. Here S(r,t) = E(r,t)\timesH(r,t) is the Poynting vector at point r in space and instant t in time, E and H are the local electromagnetic fields, and c is the speed of light in vacuum. The above statement is true irrespective of whether the waves reside in vacuum or within a ponderable medium, which medium may or may not be homogeneous, isotropic, transparent, linear, magnetic, etc. When a light pulse enters an absorbing medium, the force experienced by the medium is only partly due to the absorbed Abraham momentum. This absorbed momentum, of course, is manifested as Lorentz force (while the pulse is being extinguished within the absorber), but not all the Lorentz force experienced by the medium is attributable to the absorbed Abraham momentum. We consider an absorptive/reflective medium having the complex refractive index n_2+ik_2, submerged in a transparent dielectric of refractive index n_1, through which light must travel to reach the absorber/reflector. Depending on the impedance-mismatch between the two media, which mismatch is dependent on n_1, n_2, k_2, either more or less light will be coupled into the absorber/reflector. The dependence of this impedance-mismatch on n_1 is entirely responsible for the appearance of the Minkowski momentum in certain radiation pressure experiments that involve submerged objects.