Dynamical eigenfunctions and critical density in loop quantum cosmology

TL;DR

This paper presents a new, physically transparent proof for the universal maximum matter density in loop quantum cosmology, based on an ultraviolet cutoff in the eigenfunctions of the quantum dynamical operator.

Contribution

It introduces a novel argument for the critical density using the ultraviolet cutoff, supported by exact solutions and a new proof in the volume representation.

Findings

Existence of a sharp exponential ultraviolet cutoff in eigenfunctions.

Operators for scalar momentum and volume approximately commute.

Eigenfunctions approach superpositions of Wheeler-DeWitt eigenfunctions at large volume.

Abstract

We offer a new, physically transparent argument for the existence of the critical, universal maximum matter density in loop quantum cosmology for the case of a flat Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker cosmology with scalar matter. The argument is based on the existence of a sharp exponential ultraviolet cutoff in momentum space on the eigenfunctions of the quantum cosmological dynamical evolution operator (the gravitational part of the Hamiltonian constraint), attributable to the fundamental discreteness of spatial volume in loop quantum cosmology. The existence of the cutoff is proved directly from recently found exact solutions for the eigenfunctions for this model. As a consequence, the operators corresponding to the momentum of the scalar field and the spatial volume approximately commute. The ultraviolet cutoff then implies that the scalar momentum, though not a bounded operator, is in effect bounded on subspaces of constant volume, leading to the upper bound on the expectation value of the matter density. The maximum matter density is universal (i.e. independent of the quantum state) because of the linear scaling of the cutoff with volume. These heuristic arguments are supplemented by a new proof in the volume representation of the existence of the maximum matter density. The techniques employed to demonstrate the existence of the cutoff also allow us to extract the large volume limit of the exact eigenfunctions, confirming earlier numerical and analytical work showing that the eigenfunctions approach superpositions of the eigenfunctions of the Wheeler-DeWitt quantization of the same model. We argue that generic (not just semiclassical) quantum states approach symmetric superpositions of expanding and contracting universes.