Does loop quantum cosmology replace the big rip singularity by a non-singular bounce?

TL;DR

This paper critically examines claims that loop quantum cosmology can avoid the big rip singularity, arguing that consistent quantum modifications do not eliminate the singularity and discussing implications of quantum effects on cosmic evolution.

Contribution

It clarifies the inconsistency in previous approaches claiming big rip avoidance via holonomy corrections and explores alternative quantum effects that do not prevent the singularity.

Findings

Holonomy corrections lead to inconsistent modifications of Friedmann's equation.

Ignoring gravitational modifications, the big rip persists in loop quantum cosmology.

Quantum effects via Wheeler-De Witt equation do not eliminate the big rip singularity.

Abstract

It is stated that holonomy corrections in loop quantum cosmology introduce a modification in Friedmann's equation which prevent the big rip singularity. Recently in \cite{h12} it has been proved that this modified Friedmann equation is obtained in an inconsistent way, what means that the results deduced from it, in particular the big rip singularity avoidance, are not justified. The problem is that holonomy corrections modify the gravitational part of the Hamiltonian of the system leading, after Legendre's transformation, to a non covariant Lagrangian which is in contradiction with one of the main principles of General Relativity. A more consistent way to deal with the big rip singularity avoidance is to disregard modification in the gravitational part of the Hamiltonian, and only consider inverse volume effects \cite{bo02a}. In this case we will see that, not like the big bang singularity, the big rip singularity survives in loop quantum cosmology. Another way to deal with the big rip avoidance is to take into account geometric quantum effects given by the the Wheeler-De Witt equation. In that case, even though the wave packets spread, the expectation values satisfy the same equations as their classical analogues. Then, following the viewpoint adopted in loop quantum cosmology, one can conclude that the big rip singularity survives when one takes into account these quantum effects. However, the spreading of the wave packets prevents the recover of the semiclassical time, and thus, one might conclude that the classical evolution of the universe come to and end before the big rip is reached. This is not conclusive because. as we will see, it always exists other external times that allows us to define the classical and quantum evolution of the universe up to the big rip singularity.