Routing Regardless of Network Stability

TL;DR

This paper studies packet routing effectiveness under node filtering constraints, revealing computational hardness in some cases but also providing algorithms that guarantee packet delivery with probability one in specific scenarios.

Contribution

It introduces a new model for routing with filtering lists, proves inapproximability results, and offers probabilistic algorithms ensuring eventual packet delivery.

Findings

NP-hardness of approximation for certain filtering list sizes

Packets route with probability one when filtering lists contain only the node itself

Packets also route with probability one when filtering lists are empty

Abstract

We examine the effectiveness of packet routing in this model for the broad class next-hop preferences with filtering. Here each node v has a filtering list D(v) consisting of nodes it does not want its packets to route through. Acceptable paths (those that avoid nodes in the filtering list) are ranked according to the next-hop, that is, the neighbour of v that the path begins with. On the negative side, we present a strong inapproximability result. For filtering lists of cardinality at most one, given a network in which an equilibrium is guaranteed to exist, it is NP-hard to approximate the maximum number of packets that can be routed to within a factor of O(n^{1-\epsilon}), for any constant \epsilon >0. On the positive side, we give algorithms to show that in two fundamental cases every packet will eventually route with probability one. The first case is when each node's filtering list contains only itself, that is, D(v)={v}. Moreover, with positive probability every packet will be routed before the control plane reaches an equilibrium. The second case is when all the filtering lists are empty, that is, $\mathcal{D}(v)=\emptyset$. Thus, with probability one packets will route even when the nodes don't care if their packets cycle! Furthermore, with probability one every packet will route even when the control plane has em no equilibrium at all.