The abundance of C3H2 and other small hydrocarbons in the diffuse interstellar medium

TL;DR

This study measures small hydrocarbon abundances in the diffuse interstellar medium, challenging previous claims that certain molecules could explain diffuse interstellar bands, and finds their column densities are too low for such roles.

Contribution

The paper provides new radio absorption measurements of cyclic and linear C3H2, showing their abundances are insufficient to account for diffuse interstellar bands.

Findings

Column densities of l-C3H2 are much lower than needed to explain DIBs.

Small hydrocarbons like C4H are present but at low levels.

Abundances vary between diffuse and dark clouds, affecting their DIB carrier potential.

Abstract

Hydrocarbons are ubiquitous in the interstellar medium, observed in diverse environments ranging from diffuse to molecular dark clouds and strong photon-dominated regions near HII regions. Recently, two broad diffuse interstellar bands (DIBs) at 4881{\AA} and 5450{\AA} were attributed to the linear version of propynylidene l-C3H2, a species whose more stable cyclic conformer c-C3H2 has been widely observed in the diffuse interstellar medium at radio wavelengths. This attribution has already been criticized on the basis of indirect plausibility arguments because the required column densities are quite large, N(l-C3H2)/EB-V = 4 \times 1014 cm-2 mag-1. Here we present new measurements of N(l-C3H2) based on simultaneous 18-21 GHz VLA absorption profiles of cyclic and linear C3H2 taken along sightlines toward extragalactic radiocontinuum background sources with foreground Galactic reddening EB-V = 0.1 - 1.6 mag. We find that N(l-C3H2)/N(c-C3H2) ? 1/15 - 1/40 and N(l-C3H2)/EB-V ? 2 \pm 1 \times 1011 cm-2 mag-1, so that the column densities of l-C3H2 needed to explain the diffuse interstellar bands are some three orders of magnitude higher than what is observed. We also find N(C4H)/EB-V < 1.3 \times 1013 cm-2 mag-1 and N(C4H-)/EB-V < 1 \times 1011 cm-2 mag-1 (3?). Using available data for CH and C2H we compare the abundances of small hydrocarbons in diffuse and dark clouds as a guide to their ability to contribute as DIB carriers over a wide range of conditions in the interstellar medium.