Overabundance of alpha-elements in exoplanet host stars

TL;DR

This study compares chemical abundances in stars with and without planets, revealing that certain alpha-elements are more abundant in planet-hosting stars, especially at low metallicities, which impacts planet formation theories.

Contribution

It provides a detailed chemical abundance analysis of 1111 stars, highlighting the role of alpha-elements in planet formation and their correlation with stellar populations.

Findings

Alpha-elements like Mg, Al, Si, Sc, Ti are higher in planet hosts at low metallicity.

Neptunian hosts are more associated with thick disk stars and high-alpha populations.

Metallicity alone does not determine planet formation; chemical composition is crucial.

Abstract

We present the results for a chemical abundance analysis between planet-hosting and stars without planets for 12 refractory elements for a total of 1111 nearby FGK dwarf stars observed within the context of the HARPS GTO programs. Of these stars, 109 are known to harbour high-mass planetary companions and 26 stars are hosting exclusively Neptunians and super-Earths. We found that the [X/Fe] ratios for Mg, Al, Si, Sc, and Ti both for giant and low-mass planet hosts are systematically higher than those of comparison stars at low metallicities ([Fe/H] < from -0.2 to 0.1 dex depending on the element). The most evident discrepancy between planet-hosting and stars without planets is observed for Mg. Our data suggest that the planet incidence is greater among the thick disk population than among the thin disk for mettallicities bellow -0.3 dex. After examining the [alpha/Fe] trends of the planet host and non-host samples we conclude that a certain chemical composition, and not the Galactic birth place of the stars, is the determinating factor for that. The inspection of the Galactic orbital parameters and kinematics of the planet-hosting stars shows that Neptunian hosts tend to belong to the "thicker" disk compared to their high-mass planet-hosting counterparts.We also found that Neptunian hosts follow the distribution of high-alpha stars in the UW vs V velocities space, but they are more enhanced in Mg than high-alpha stars without planetary companions. Our results indicate that some metals other than iron may also have an important contribution to planet formation if the amount of iron is low. These results may provide strong constraints for the models of planet formation, especially for planets with low mass.