Comment on the paper I. M. Suslov: Finite Size Scaling from the Self Consistent Theory of Localization

TL;DR

This paper critically evaluates Suslov's proposed finite size scaling theory of electron localization, demonstrating through numerical data that it does not align with observed results in the Anderson model.

Contribution

It provides a critical analysis showing that Suslov's scaling theory is not supported by numerical evidence from the Anderson model.

Findings

Numerical data contradict Suslov's predictions.

The paper challenges the validity of the proposed scaling theory.

Supports existing understanding of electron localization phenomena.

Abstract

In the recent paper [I.M.Suslov, JETP {\bf 114} (2012) 107] a new scaling theory of electron localization was proposed. We show that numerical data for the quasi-one dimensional Anderson model do not support predictions of this theory.