Stable counteralignment of a circumbinary disc

TL;DR

This paper investigates the alignment behavior of circumbinary discs around supermassive black hole binaries, showing that typical parameters favor full co- or counter-alignment, with stability of retrograde discs also established.

Contribution

It demonstrates that under typical conditions, misaligned discs tend to fully co- or counter-align, and establishes the stability of retrograde circumbinary discs, extending understanding of disc-binary interactions.

Findings

Discs with typical parameters tend to fully co- or counter-align.

Retrograde circumbinary discs are stable.

Extreme binary parameters can lead to simultaneous co- and counter-alignment.

Abstract

In general, when gas accretes on to a supermassive black hole binary it is likely to have no prior knowledge of the binary angular momentum. Therefore a circumbinary disc forms with a random inclination angle, theta, to the binary. It is known that for theta < 90 degrees the disc will coalign wrt the binary. If theta > 90 degrees the disc wholly counteraligns if it satisfies cos(theta) < -J_d/2J_b, where J_d and J_b are the magnitudes of the disc and binary angular momentum vectors respectively. If however theta > 90 degrees and this criterion is not satisfied the same disc may counteralign its inner regions and, on longer timescales, coalign its outer regions. I show that for typical disc parameters, describing an accretion event on to a supermassive black hole binary, a misaligned circumbinary disc is likely to wholly co-- or counter--align with the binary plane. This is because the binary angular momentum dominates the disc angular momentum. However with extreme parameters (binary mass ratio M_2/M_1 << 1 or binary eccentricity e ~ 1) the same disc may simultaneously co- and counter-align. It is known that coplanar prograde circumbinary discs are stable. I show that coplanar retrograde circumbinary discs are also stable. A chaotic accretion event on to an SMBH binary will therefore result in a coplanar circumbinary disc that is either prograde or retrograde with respect to the binary plane.