The magnetic fields of hot subdwarf stars

TL;DR

This study critically re-evaluates previous claims of magnetic fields in hot subdwarf stars, finding no strong evidence for such fields and suggesting they are rare or absent in these stars.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive re-analysis of existing data and new observations, clarifying the prevalence of magnetic fields in hot subdwarfs and addressing previous measurement inconsistencies.

Findings

No strong magnetic fields detected in the sample.

Previous detections likely due to calibration issues.

Magnetic fields stronger than 1-2 kG are very rare or absent.

Abstract

Detection of magnetic fields has been reported in several sdO and sdB stars. Recent literature has cast doubts on the reliability of most of these detections. We revisit data previously published in the literature, and we present new observations to clarify the question of how common magnetic fields are in subdwarf stars. We consider a sample of about 40 hot subdwarf stars. About 30 of them have been observed with the FORS1 and FORS2 instruments of the ESO VLT. Here we present new FORS1 field measurements for 17 stars, 14 of which have never been observed for magnetic fields before. We also critically review the measurements already published in the literature, and in particular we try to explain why previous papers based on the same FORS1 data have reported contradictory results. All new and re-reduced measurements obtained with FORS1 are shown to be consistent with non-detection of magnetic fields. We explain previous spurious field detections from data obtained with FORS1 as due to a non-optimal method of wavelength calibration. Field detections in other surveys are found to be uncertain or doubtful, and certainly in need of confirmation. There is presently no strong evidence for the occurrence of a magnetic field in any sdB or sdO star, with typical longitudinal field uncertainties of the order of 2-400 G. It appears that globally simple fields of more than about 1 or 2 kG in strength occur in at most a few percent of hot subdwarfs, and may be completely absent at this strength. Further high-precision surveys, both with high-resolution spectropolarimeters and with instruments similar to FORS1 on large telescopes, would be very valuable.