Formation of '3D' multiplanet systems by dynamical disruption of multiple-resonance configurations

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new formation scenario for 3D multiplanet systems involving the dynamical disruption of resonant configurations, leading to high inclinations and ejections, based on simulations of planetary migration and resonance interactions.

Contribution

It introduces an alternative formation mechanism for 3D systems via resonance instability and planetary scattering, supported by detailed N-body simulations.

Findings

Triple resonances often become unstable, causing planet ejections.

Ejected planets can have inclinations up to 40 degrees relative to the initial plane.

Remaining two-planet systems can have high mutual inclinations up to 70 degrees.

Abstract

Assuming that giant planets are formed in thin protoplanetary discs, a '3D' system can form, provided that the mutual inclination is excited by some dynamical mechanism. Resonant interactions and close planetary encounters are thought to be the primary inclination-excitation mechanisms, resulting in a resonant and non-resonant system, respectively. Here we propose an alternative formation scenario, starting from a system composed of three giant planets in a nearly coplanar configuration. As was recently shown for the case of the Solar system, planetary migration in the gas disc (Type II migration) can force the planets to become trapped in a multiply resonant state. We simulate this process, assuming different values for the planetary masses and mass ratios. We show that such a triple resonance generally becomes unstable as the resonance excites the eccentricities of all planets and planet-planet scattering sets in. One of the three planets is typically ejected from the system, leaving behind a dynamically 'hot' (but stable) two-planet configuration. The resulting two-planet systems typically have large values of semimajor axial ratios (a1/a2 < 0.3), while the mutual inclination can be as high as 70{\deg}, with a median of \sim30{\deg}. A small fraction of our two-planet systems (\sim5 per cent) ends up in the stability zone of the Kozai resonance. In a few cases, the triple resonance can remain stable for long times and a '3D' system can form by resonant excitation of the orbital inclinations; such a three-planet system could be stable if enough eccentricity damping is exerted on the planets. Finally, in the single-planet resulting systems, which are formed when two planets are ejected from the system, the inclination of the planet's orbital plane with respect to the initial invariant plane -presumably the plane perpendicular to the star's spin axis- can be as large as \sim40{\deg}.